Which Test Is Best For You? ACT or SAT?
More students took the ACT than the SAT for the first time in 2012, ending the SAT’s reign as America’s most popular university-entrance standardized test. Since then, the ACT’s popularity has only continued to grow. This shift toward the ACT was at least partially the result of students often preferring the ACT’s more content-based style of questioning. Many students wanted to avoid the SAT’s more reasoning-based style of questioning that felt quite different from what they typically encountered in the classroom. However, in March 2016, The College Board released a completely revamped SAT, designed to be more similar to the ACT, and further complicating decision-making for college admissions test preparation.
As you consider taking the ACT versus the SAT, think about the following:
Timing. Does it work for you or against you?
The most significant difference between the tests is that the ACT is faster paced and benefits students who push through questions quickly. The new SAT provides a less intense pacing experience.
- The ACT Math section consists of 60 questions in 60 minutes (60 seconds per question) whereas the SAT Math sections spread 58 questions over 2 sections for a total of 80 minutes (83 seconds per question).
- The ACT English and Reading sections pose 115 questions over 80 minutes (42 seconds per question) while the SAT Language and Reading sections contain 96 questions in 100 minutes (63 seconds per question).
- If you have extended time accommodations due to a learning difference, the pacing issue is largely mitigated. In other words, the timing difference will not matter. The ACT has a Science section while the new SAT intersperses such questions throughout the test. In both cases, students are often surprised to learn that these question types are more skill-based than fact-based (e.g. interpreting graphs and charts) and don’t require outside scientific knowledge. With structured practice, students can greatly improve from their initial diagnostic ACT Science section score. However, for students who really do not like the ACT’s Science section, the new SAT may be a more appealing choice.
How do you feel about Science?
The ACT has a Science section while the new SAT intersperses such questions throughout the test. In both cases, students are often surprised to learn that these question types are more skill-based than fact-based (e.g. interpreting graphs and charts) and don’t require outside scientific knowledge. With structured practice, students can greatly improve from their initial diagnostic ACT Science section score. However, for students who really do not like the ACT’s Science section, the new SAT may be a more appealing choice.
Are you confident without your calculator?
While the ACT allows a calculator on all math questions, the new SAT contains twenty “no calculator” math problems. While putting your calculator aside for about a third of the SAT’s math questions may initially sound intimidating, these questions do not require complicated arithmetic. Most students do not find the lack of calculator to be an issue. If anything, a calculator would probably slow students down on the “no calculator” question type.
Do you have a preferred essay format? This is probably the least significant of the differences between the two tests. The ACT asks students to choose a side of an argument and support it. The SAT asks students to evaluate somebody else’s written argument. An advantage to the ACT essay is that students choose from one of three stances and then justify it, thus eliminating the challenge of developing a unique thesis statement. For many students, this format is more manageable.
Additionally, because the latest iteration of the SAT is still so new, far fewer practice tests and other preparation materials exist for it. This alone is often a disadvantage and cause for students to choose the ACT until more SAT data and materials exist. For now, there is still limited data in terms of concordance charts and interpreting SAT results.
So, which test is the better choice?
It is a myth that one test is markedly easier than the other. Most students perform similarly on both tests. Making a decision between ACT or SAT for university admissions test preparation depends mostly on your personal preferences as a test taker. Therefore, it’s worthwhile to find out early if you have a clear preference for either test. Switching back and forth between tests or trying to prepare for both simultaneously is not an efficient use of precious test preparation time.
In addition, colleges and universities do not prefer one test over the other. Preparing for the ACT or SAT both require hours of dedicated practice and sustained hard work to master the relevant content and internalize the necessary test-taking strategies. A strong score on either test provides admission officers with the same information since the content and format of the tests are similar. And don’t forget, your standardized test scores are just one part of your university application!
Should you write the ESSAY portion of the test or not?
More and more universities are dropping their requirement for the SAT or ACT essay. A few (including the University of California system) still require it. A few recommend it. Given that the essay appears to be on its way out, we are no longer including the essay in our test prep classes. For students wising to prepare for the Essay portion, Frazer Roland of Can-Am Test Prep will be offering
a 2-day workshop focused on the essay during the fall season and again in the spring. He will provide information and details during his class with you. Once you are done with the course, you can also book private lessons with him to cover the essay portion or to work on your areas of weakness once you have done a mock test or two to determine which sections you need more help on.
Arguments for ACT:
- If the student is an overall strong student in a rigorous academic program, then they will do well in the ACT because it is a more straightforward test.
- If the student is able to work fast.
- There are 215 MC (multiple choice) questions on the ACT compared to 152 MC questions on the SAT. You are given 40 minutes for the essay on the ACT compared to 50 minutes on the SAT.
- If the student is applying to STEM programs or the sciences, the fact that the ACT has a science section they can do well in to showcase their science chops, can be a plus for them.
- Does NOT provide the formulas for math
- Calculators are permitted on all math sections.
- There is equal emphasis on geometry and algebra.
Arguments for SAT:
- If English is a second language for the student and therefore they might be a little slower in processing, the SAT might be best because it gives them more time per question.
- However, given the facts that some questions might be somewhat tricky (less straightforward), a student might need more time in solving these questions.
- Provide some geometry formulas for math section.
- It has less geometry but more algebra related questions.
- There is one math section where a calculator is not permitted
- There are some questions in both math sections (with and without calculator) where a student has to generate and enter the response (not multiple choice).
- There are more word problem-solving questions in math.
- There are multiple-choice questions about the US constitution and history with which Canadian students might have less familiarity.
Test Information Release (TIR): Students can order the TIR during registration or any time up to five days after the test administration, they’ll receive a copy of the test answers for review after they receive their scores. The TIR costs $20, and there are additional charges to receive a photocopy of the answer sheet or essay, if applicable. The ACT only offers the TIR service in December, April, and June, so students should take advantage of it when they can, as it can be a very helpful resource for understanding their scores. For more information, visit the ACT’s TIR page here.
For further information and sample questions for the SAT and ACT, please refer to their websites:
Here are the differences SAT vs. ACT: